Get Britain Building!
All Episodes
Unlocking Investment for NHS Rebuilding

Unlocking Investment for NHS Rebuilding

0:00|0:00
Fraser Spence and Mary Devereux discuss how the UK can bring vital private capital into the NHS for urgent rebuilding, with insight from Lord Hutton and analysis from the AIIP. They examine the evidence for modern, transparent PPP models and the pressing need for reform ahead of the autumn budget.

This show was created with Jellypod, the AI Podcast Studio. Create your own podcast with Jellypod today.


Chapter 1

The Scale of the NHS Infrastructure Crisis

Fraser Spence

Hello and welcome to Get Britain Building! I’m Fraser Spence and with me is Mary Devereux. Today, we're talking about a topic that, well, is kind of impossible to ignore if you step into any hospital or GP surgery up and down the country—the crumbling reality of NHS infrastructure. And Mary, let’s be honest, those statistics are bleak. We’re talking about a £49 billion backlog in maintenance alone. That’s not a typo. And if you look around the average NHS building, it’s no wonder: four in ten of those buildings are more than forty years old—

Mary Devereux

—Yeah Fraser, and just let that settle for a second: forty years. And even older, actually—one in seven hospitals in England was built before 1945. So not only is the NHS chronically underfunded on the day-to-day, but it’s fighting an uphill battle just keeping the roof from leaking. And sometimes, that roof literally leaks. Which, funny—or maybe not funny at all—but that happened to me last month on a visit to my local A&E. We were in this small waiting corridor, and there were buckets out everywhere because the ceiling was just… dripping. There were these warning signs, but nobody even blinked. Staff just shrugged—as if it was totally normal.

Fraser Spence

That’s a vivid picture, Mary, but I think you’re right. It’s almost become background noise, hasn’t it? But what isn’t background noise is the real human cost: the National Audit Office says 5,400 clinical service incidents a year are caused just by this failing infrastructure. Departments shut down, operations delayed, appointments cancelled. It’s not some abstract, budgetary problem—it’s very, very real for patients and staff.

Mary Devereux

And the delays just seem to be baked in now, don’t they? That big promise a few years back—forty new hospitals? It sounded bold, but now some of those won’t even start building until, what was it, 2039? It’s wild to think how long people will be waiting for facilities that are actually safe and functional. And let’s not forget, all this only puts more pressure on waiting lists, which are already at record highs.

Fraser Spence

Exactly. And look, if we don’t sort out these buildings, no amount of clever reform plans or extra doctors are going to fix the system. The walls themselves are holding us back. It sounds dramatic, but the data backs it up: over two thousand buildings are older than the NHS itself. That’s—you couldn’t make it up if you tried. So, given all this, it’s not surprising the debate’s really ramping up on how we actually get the money and momentum to fix things.

Chapter 2

Learning from the Past: What PPPs and PFIs Got Right (and Wrong)

Mary Devereux

Yeah, and Fraser, this is where everyone suddenly seems to have an opinion on public-private partnerships—PPPs, and of course, the infamous PFI. But here’s the bit that surprised me, digging into the actual evidence: back in the late 90s and early 2000s, PFI actually got 90 hospitals built in less than a decade. Pretty much unheard of before or since, right?

Fraser Spence

You’re spot on. I remember reporting on one of those projects way back—at the time, honestly, there was a ton of scepticism. People worried about cost overruns, delays. But the National Audit Office and several other reports have said, you know, most of the hospitals were actually delivered on time, on budget—even better than traditional procurement. I always thought that kind of flew under the radar, because the public debate was so much about the negatives.

Mary Devereux

And the negatives were real, weren’t they? Some contracts got too complicated, or you’d hear about stories where maintenance costs spiralled—but if you zoom out, internationally, countries like Australia, Canada, New Zealand—loads of them are still using updated PPP models. No one’s saying it’s perfect, but they keep getting hospitals and schools built, and… well, nobody’s waiting twenty years for a leaky ceiling to get fixed.

Fraser Spence

It’s almost ironic. The UK was an early pioneer of PPPs, but now we’re really lagging behind. And there’s actually solid analysis—like that Infrastructure Partnerships Australia report—showing that PPPs delivered better cost efficiency than traditional methods: something like a third cheaper when you count it from project inception. And the National Audit Office—this is just earlier this year—they said PPP projects are usually delivered on time and on budget.

Mary Devereux

And it’s not just about buildings, either. The thing people forget is, PPPs—when they work—can factor in maintenance so you don’t end up back at square one five or ten years down the line. The NHS Confederation even said the value for money from old PFI hospitals often beats the recent New Hospitals Programme, once you factor in how badly those new builds have been delayed, or how much extra they cost.

Fraser Spence

Of course, we can’t ignore what didn’t work: some contracts were overly complex, performance metrics running into the hundreds, and disputes dragging out. There are definitely lessons to learn. But if it means we could avoid decades of delay, it’s worth having an honest conversation about what worked and what didn’t.

Chapter 3

Modern Reform: How New PPP Models Could Unlock Billions

Mary Devereux

So let’s talk solutions, because that’s what everyone’s clamouring for, especially heading into this budget. Lord Hutton and the AIIP report both say, look, we know the old way had flaws—but new PPP models could actually work, if we bake in transparency and proper oversight. You’d have independent certifiers to keep things accountable, and use digital models so everyone can see how the project’s actually performing. That’s a real shift, isn’t it?

Fraser Spence

Yeah, and performance metrics—this is a big one. Instead of having 500 different measures buried in a contract, new proposals say, measure what matters and keep it simple. Less red tape, more focus on outcomes. And another point I think is crucial: these reforms want to let private investment properly into rebuilding hospitals, not just small neighbourhood health centres. If that changes, it could unleash, well—what do they call it?—a wall of capital that’s just waiting to be invested here instead of flying off to Australia or New Zealand.

Mary Devereux

That’s the sense I’m getting too. There’s a risk if we drag our feet, the money will just go elsewhere. Investors have, not to be dramatic, but they’ve warned openly that they’re looking at other countries if things stay so unclear. The new model is about making sure risk sits with the people actually best placed to manage it—not just shifting it onto taxpayers. That’s got to help restore trust after some of the horror stories of the past.

Fraser Spence

There’s still some healthy scepticism, especially from people who saw how the old PFI deals went wrong. But the sense from the AIIP and NHS leaders is that the status quo isn’t working. What’s interesting is, even Jim Mackey—the NHS England chief—has come out and said, we need new partnerships to upgrade NHS buildings and tech. The window is open, and if this chance is missed, we’re back to leaky ceilings, waiting another ten years for upgrades.

Mary Devereux

So it’s really a case of, we have the evidence, we’ve seen what works elsewhere, and it’s about actually acting, not just promising. And maybe unpicking some of that old ideology that’s, like, holding back real progress out of fear of repeating the same mistakes. If we get the transparency and the oversight right, the potential for tackling those huge waiting lists and relentless building failures is actually within reach.

Fraser Spence

Absolutely. Well, that's probably a good spot to leave today’s debate. The NHS needs urgent fixes, and if the reforms are in place, we might finally see some doors opening for that all-important investment. But look, we’ll be back very soon to keep following how this shakes out around the autumn budget and what comes next. Mary, always good to chat, thanks for joining me.

Mary Devereux

Thanks Fraser. I’ll try not to bring any more leaky ceiling stories, but, you never know! Thanks to everyone for listening. See you next time!